Comments on: The Hindu Conversion to Islam

By: amit

amit — Wed, 25 Nov 2009 17:12:59 +0000

I think that this country may become a great blessing for the oppressed , poor Muslims. One may wonder about the poverty of Muslims in this country although it grants more freedom and opportunity to Muslims than most Muslim countries. The reason are manifold. Muslims are divided into different groups or tribes which is other way of saying caste. This can not be solely blamed as hindu influences. This is very important point to note that unless Muslims dissolve distinctions like ansari, shaikh, pathan etc our community is not going anywhere. I have been to USA and I have studied extensively societies of Jews, Jains and Europeans. Believe me, unless we produce a super-community of Indian Muslims, we will have little power or at most the power will be concentrated in a few hands, and not benefit the community. At least we should form a combined community of existing rich Muslims and high caste Hindu converts. Because to spread Islam in India, it is now crystal clear that the three main castes in India Brahmans, Rajputs and Banias had to convert. Else we would fail like we failed during last 1400 years. Think over it !

By: Hamaid

Hamaid — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 21:03:02 +0000

Can you tell naxalites and maoists about hindu rituals and practices. will u bring them to peace. We can also try and by the way there are many muslim organisation who are trying to correct them. But the current conditions in such regions is out of control and people are not allowed to reach there. We can only try, rest is left on people whether they want to follow it or not. If they are ignorant and wrong, than we cannot help. My religion is peaceful, they have to give answer to God one day. till then keep trying.

By: Hamaid

Hamaid — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 20:53:31 +0000

Let me answer your questions.
1) There is nothing in Quran where Muslims are not allowed to convert to any other religion. well, it is written that there is no compulsion in religion so you can convert. look into the internet and in Asian regions, there are many ignorant Muslims have converted to Christianity n other religions.
2) Muhammad (PBUH) never married a 9 years old girl. It is written in Hadith which is doubtful. We can easily conclude that he married to Aisha when she was 12 or 13 years old since she was born in yume jahiliya i.e. before the Muhammad (PBUH) messangership and he married to Aisha after moving to madinah i.e 10 years n it is also known that prophet (PBUH) married to Aisha (R) 2 years later. What you want to say for mary who got pregnant with Jesus Christ at the age of 12. What will you say when she was married of to an old man of 90's. Do you have any comment for Sita who got married when she was only 6 year old.
3) ISLAM clearly states that there is nothing like giving name to any baby. Zed (R) divorced his wife and prophet married her after the revelation that adopted son will not be recognised as there own Son.
4) Islam is peaceful but people can be wrong. Look at Hitler killing of innocent jews, can u blame christianity for it or mumbai or godhra riots, will u label hindu responsible for it.
5) Prayers is for us, it doesn't mean that we can be in 100 % peace just on offering prayers 5 times a day. we have to find ALLAH's love in our prayers which u seriously lack.
6) thanks to your GOD that atleast you can marry, see the other poor innocent women who cannot find man in this world. Can you see yourself as a prostitute in there place. Just for just cause. There is nothing like marry only in any other scriptures but ISLAM.
7) You are wrong here completely. State with proof and reference. Our prophet never destroyed anything. Liar SARA.
Quran is the only book preserved in its original form.
9) Its your problem, you believe in people as your God and helper but we muslim believe in God.
10) Learn Quran and search about it. u will surely find peace. inshallah

By: zak

zak — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 15:23:27 +0000

dr brother abhi,
u have often heard LITTLE KNOWLEDGE DANGEROUS THING.if u really wants to know the real facts of islam.go to deep to earn real pearl, something i wil tell u muslims are niether god/god son/any way link to god .the whole humankind is on one purpose to worship creator of this univearse.naturally he knows better than us.i wil approve ur some of the words 'jiziya,Dhimmis etc .but u never say that quran says that all muslims by name will go to heavens.there are lots of MUNAFIQS( claiming muslims performing all duties but from heart they are non bielever,means they dont accept in monothism)these type are worst creatures on earth even from non bieliever.they claims but but alas they are blacksheeps of community.it exist every where in every country.allah swt knows best.we cannot even abuse any hindus,christian .jews,other claimed religion.MY DEAR MAY BE UR OFFSPRING GENERATION ACCEPT THIS MONOTHISM.our last prophet his own uncle didnt accept islam.then how can be he prophets i wil tell u real muslims always bielieve in creator not in creation.so try hard to filter as u know now world are modernized so u can develope some sofwares.i knows answers is impossible .BUT GOD AND ISLAM CLAIMS IT WILL BE AFTER DOOMSDAY.EVERYPERSON WILL BE ABLE TO SEE HIS GOOD AND BAD DEEDS.U KNOW FOR GOD IT IS VERY EASY.IF AHUMANBIENG CAN DO RECORDING WHY NOT GOD.(creator)so dear friend understand the facts of islam and accept with hearts.insallah u will be also rewarded by god.

By: Abhishek

Abhishek — Thu, 12 Nov 2009 02:00:56 +0000

Ruby, The Imrana Rape case and the appalling ruling of the Islamic court thereafter is out for anyone who seeks to see the truth. Even you can't disagree that women are considered inferior to men in Islam (please don't interpret my words in a strictly technical sense, I'm obviously implying in a general sense). Is it not true that in case of rape of a Muslim woman, she has to procure four male Muslim witnesses in the Islamic court of law to prove the assault? Is it also not true that the testimony of a non-believer in an Islamic court holds no value when compared to the testimony of a Muslim man? You know as well as anyone else that some Islamic countries are the worst offenders where treatment of minorities and human rights are concerned (case in point: the ongoing genocide of Hindus in Pakistan whose population has dropped by a factor of 25 in just 60 years!). Sure there are good Muslims, but they seem to have no political presence or will to curb the fanatics and zealots? How do you expect people to believe the oft said 'Islam is a religion of peace' when it expressly discriminates between believers and non-believers and sometimes describes borderline psychotic methods to humble and humiliate 'Dhimmis' and other non-believers with imposition of taxes such as the 'jiziya' and ruinous methods of extracting them? I can refer to many sites where translations of the Koran are available with exact extractions mentioned therein, but I'm sure you'll call them anti-Islam and so on.

By: LG

LG — Thu, 05 Nov 2009 15:50:00 +0000

Regarding Zakir Naik... He was meant to be a lawyer... he just quotes page numbers and phrases w/o context, and cannot accept arguments. He is biased towards Islam, and uses other religions' books (page numbers/ chapters without context and full explanation) just to justify his beliefs.. It's totally fine with me if he believes in and supports Islam, coz even I'm a muslim - but I don't like his baseless claims against Hinduism and Christianity with the sole intention of debunking them. For example - his lecture of "GOD" in hinduism. In Islam - everything was created by god. This is true, and I follow this because it helps me to spirituality In Hinduism. He says "everything is god". Well, thats NOT the true interpretation of Hinduism. What Hinduism means is that .. God is Omnipresent.. Hes not a person who exists to control the world... He;s collectively the good and spiritual being in all mankind and living being... and that if we concentrate, we can realize the god inside us and inside other people. Hinduism is a very tolerant religion, and requires a lot of intelligence to understand... BUT Zakir Naik failed to explain this concept being a "scholar" of Hinduism. So fellow muslims, PLEASE don't ever quote him as a an unbiased scholar of religions and tarnish the image of islam.. it's already been tarnished by terrorists Ex President of India - ABDUL KALAM is a true scholar of religions!

By: Ruby

Ruby — Sat, 31 Oct 2009 14:52:31 +0000

My friend, as a muslim i condemn this happening, if its true. Am glad that the strike was called. What do you suggest, for how many days shud people of Gujrath go for strike, when so many women were raped and killed ? Be honest my friend ! You need not answer here, but answer your conscious, if its alive !

By: Ruby

Ruby — Sat, 31 Oct 2009 14:48:59 +0000

Hello Steve,

Can you support your claim about the ideology of Islam you presented, by Qur'an since, its the only testament of Allah that we follow.

The rape, gangrape, torture, and what not ! Are this not done by christians, hindus ? Whats the reason that even today, its an attractive religion thats spreading not by force, though in your words, it holds so much of wrong things ?

Am a muslim. Never did i commit any of the crimes you stated ! Since i know, Islam does n't encourage, infact we are punished, if we do all those infallible

By: Ruby

Ruby — Sat, 31 Oct 2009 14:43:48 +0000

The site - link you shared is an anti-islamic site. They present themselves as muslims, but hold all those things not taught and preached in Islam.

By: Ruby

Ruby — Sat, 31 Oct 2009 14:41:37 +0000

Hello Rajesh,
You hold lots of frustration with muslims ! Insha Allah, you shall not find us crticising any other religion. Can you support claims, by authentic scriptures of muslims, i.e from Qur'an and the books of life of Muhammad {Pbuh}. You hold misconception that Muhammad {Pbuh} forcibly married Khadeejah. It was not he who forced his adopted to divorce. It was the command of Allah swt.

Where in Qur'an do you find, Rajesh that he asked his followes to rape non-muslims ?

You said :

But islam clearly oppressed women and limited their status to just sex toys.-

I pity your understanding, Next time we will have a discussion about women in Islam, insha Allah.

You said:
If you read Quran, most of verses preach violence like askign to kill infidels after sacred months passed, rape kafir women, etc.

Kindly post the source of your statements wherein you are asked to rape kafir women.

Were Narendra modi and his followers who raped sp many women in Gujrath ,muslims ?

Every man who rapes is a muslim over earth ?

You said :
How can it be a religion?

Yes, it can't be a religion of the understanding you hold. I wish you shed away your hatred for Islam, and once again read Qur'an. I did not feel it appropriate to answer every abuse of yours, which is a lie.